Pledge for New Minimum Standards in Haiti

A Haitian Solution and Rights-Based Disaster Response

A collective of organizations including Nou Pap Dòmi, Ansanm pou Ayiti, Konbit pou yon Ayiti Tèt Anwo (CHW-KATA), the Haitian Ladies’ Network, and the Haiti Response Coalition call on all those who operate in Haiti to pledge to meet these minimum standards.

August 21, 2021

We pledge to respect the dignity of the Haitian people.

We pledge to use respectful language.

We pledge to be specific, transparent and inclusive.

We pledge to respect Haitian leadership and reinforce Haitian capacity.

We pledge to support the public good.

We pledge to align with and support long-term efforts.

Above all, we pledge to hold ourselves accountable, and invite groups in Haiti, especially the communities in which we work, to hold us accountable.

WHY DO WE NEED NEW STANDARDS FOR HAITI?

 
 

On August 14, 2021, two earthquakes struck Haiti, ravaging the southern peninsula, which has yet to fully recover from the 2016 Hurricane Matthew. The 2010 earthquake that devastated the capital of Port au Prince and surrounding areas likewise still haunts Haiti.

The earthquakes’ impact was devastating and vast because of the human-made vulnerabilities that predate them. We cannot look at these events as isolated “natural disasters” but natural events turned into disasters because of human action. The humanitarian aid which followed 2010, that filmmaker Raoul Peck has called “fatal assistance” left little sustainable improvement and in fact exacerbated existing inequalities and deepened Haiti's dependence on foreign assistance. In other words, the international humanitarian response to the 2010 earthquake became another aftershock that is still being felt. Led by large international organizations, this aid followed on the heels of centuries of foreign interventions, exploitation, and economic policies that have weakened the Haitian State, essentially rendering it an aid State (often called “Republic of NGOs”) and bled the country’s resources dry.

Because of this experience, Haitians living in the country and abroad are justifiably skeptical of foreign assistance. We hope the international community will respond swiftly to this latest tragedy as it has so generously in the past. But now is a time to learn from that past, move away from “fatal assistance,” and support organizations that are a part of Haitian solutions respecting minimum standards in solidarity to a recovery that builds a more equitable Haiti for Haitians. Good intentions are not enough...good actions must follow.

 

Following Hurricane Matthew in 2016, Haitian NGO professionals and activists collaborated with U.S. peers to draft a set of “new minimum standards” to prevent repeating the mistakes of the 2010 earthquake, despite global “minimum standards” for humanitarian responses. Indeed, all groups working in aid should learn about, adopt, and aspire to follow existing standards.

Minimum Standards

There’s no time to lose.

Haitian lives deserve better.

  • DIGNITY

    We pledge to respect the dignity of Haitian people and reject the voyeuristic normalization of Black suffering. We will not use images that dehumanize people or fail to respect people’s dignity, like images of people who are naked or dirty, or that feature people who did not provide consent to being pictured.

  • RESPECT

    We pledge to use respectful language, to not use language perceived as offensive by Haitians, such as descriptions of Haiti as the “poorest country in the hemisphere” without explaining how Haiti became so poor (impoverishment vs. poor), and other clichés that have historically justified interventions that disrespected Haitian autonomy or presented Haitians as passive victims rather than autonomous individuals facing challenges that are the direct result of slavery, colonialism, and racism.

  • SPECIFICITY

    We pledge to be specific, stop collecting donations for “Haiti,” and to instead articulate specific geographic regions and particular needs that we will work to address in accordance with a context-specific assistance plan.

  • TRANSPARENCY

    We pledge to be transparent, make public our work plans for carrying out our efforts, including information on which populations will be served by certain interventions, specific strategies, and partners (along with information regarding how long we’ve worked with them and our criteria for selecting them) to the extent practicable permitted without revealing personal information or putting anyone in danger. The information will be made public on our website and, where practicable, on other public Haitian forums such as radio.

  • HAITIAN LEADERSHIP

    We pledge to respect Haitian leadership, coordinate with and/or notify national and local officials in Haiti, including the local councils (CASEC) and mayors in the area and ministry responsible for specific interventions, as well as - where appropriate for disaster response - with the corresponding sectoral working groups coordinated by UN OCHA in partnership with the Haitian Directorate for Civil Protection. We also pledge to involve local community members and civil society into the design, execution, and evaluation of projects that affect or have the potential to affect them to the extent possible.

  • INCLUSIVITY

    We pledge to be inclusive, to carry out our work in a way that prevents discrimination against historically disempowered groups such as women, sexual minorities, disabled persons and impoverished people, and to follow practices that systematically integrate members of disempowered groups into decisions about our initiatives.

  • REINFORCE CAPACITY

    We pledge to reinforce Haitian capacity, prioritize and, to the extent practicable, invest in local resources for procurement and employment. In so doing, we commit to ensuring that salaries for Haitians are sufficient to constitute a living wage commensurate with their skills or relevant knowledge.

  • SUPPORT THE PUBLIC GOOD

    We pledge to support the public good, providing aid that sustainably reinforces public structures and services, including roads, water, electricity, schools, and communication systems.

  • LONG-TERM

    We pledge to address the long-term, to be accountable to existing sustainable development efforts and have a plan to expedite the emergency phase and move into the recovery and rebuilding phases. As such we commit to sharing knowledge and any necessary tools with the affected population to enable local ownership of any ongoing activities.

Above all, we pledge to hold ourselves accountable, and invite groups in Haiti, especially the communities in which we work, to hold us accountable. We commit to respond to all local queries about our work.

Organizations who have taken the Pledge:

Quixote Center

Global Justice Clinic, NYU School of Law

Blue Butterfly/Lakou Kajou

Friends of Matènwa

Zanmi Lakay

Manifest Haiti

GOALS Haiti

Haiti Partners

Grown in Haiti

Sustainable Organic Integrated Livelihoods (SOIL)

Haitian Connection

Office of Peace, Justice, and Ecological Integrity, Sisters of Charity of Saint Elizabeth

Model School Network

Centre d'Agriculture Saint Barnabas (CASB) Support Group Ltd

Project HOPE

Nouvelle Alliance Haïtienne pour le Développement

Fatima Group

Sisters of Charity of Seton Hill

Haiti H2O: Hope to Opportunity

FSRL UNEPH

Friends of Matenwa

Project Hope

Creative Exchanges Initiative

FOCO Digital Corp

Project Medishare

Partners in Health

Smallholder Farmers Alliance

The Haiti Health Network

Roots of Development

Beyond Borders

The Haitian Women’s Collective

Project Blueprint

Just Haiti

Community Coalition for Haiti

PRODEV Foundation

Hastings to Haiti Partnership

Voix et Actions

IDETTE HAITI

Surge for Water

Strength in Unity Global and NAHADE

Congregation of the Mission

Mary House, Inc.

Sisters of Charity of Seton Hill

Grey Dove, Inc.

Unlocking Communities

Sustainable Organic Integrated Livelihoods (SOIL)

Haitian Connection

Li Li Li Read

Friends of Latin America

Haiti Foundation

Locally Haiti


Individuals who have taken the Pledge:

Cindy Corell

J. Venneman

JoJo

Bernard Angus

Julia Cuccaro/Development Director, Sisters of Charity

Carine Jocelyn

Roger Bowen

Mercedes Narcisse

Michael Anthony Carter

Mercedes Narcisse Jerry Heppes

Serena Beeks

Carmen Nieves

Sister Bernice Steele

Tara Greggaina

Janet H. Brackett

Grace Hartzog

Erin Daly

Sister Judy Laffey SC

Tim Ford

Jerry Heppes

Roger Bowen

Tim Ford

Bernadette Jones

Margaret Leonard

Sister Edith Strong